Exclusionary School Discipline Does Not Work
Years of research have shown that exclusionary school discipline methods, like suspension or expulsion, do not improve student behavior. Instead, these practices make it more likely that a student will not complete high school and more likely that they will have contact with the justice system. This is more true of students of color. Black students are 4 times more likely to be suspended than their white peers, without indication to show they misbehave more. Positive Alternatives to suspension and expulsion, such as School-Wide Positive Behavior Intervention and Support, Restorative Practices and Trauma Informed Schools are demonstrated to support students and address harsh and disproportionate school discipline. Fix School Discipline’s vision for schools is supportive schools for all students.
The materials below illustrate the problems with out-of-school suspensions, as well as research about the solutions.
For a comprehensive page of articles related to the problems and solutions of school discipline, please follow us on Facebook and Twitter.
Research Categories
Punitive School Discipline Does Not Work
- Cops and No Counselors: How the Lack of School Mental Health Staff is Harming Students (2019)
- Breaking School Rules: A Statewide Study of How School Discipline Relates to Student’s Success and Juvenile Justice Involvement (2011)
- Alternative Discipline Structures: A Comprehensive Approach to Changing Behavior (2014)
- Healthy Environments and Response to Trauma in Schools (HEARTS): A Whole School, Multi-Level, Prevention and Intervention Program for Creating Trauma-Informed, Safe, Supportive Schools (2016)
- Hambacher, E. (2017). Resisting punitive school discipline: perspectives and practices of exemplary urban elementary teachers. International Journal of Qualitative Studies in Education, 31(2), 102–118.
- Hwang, N., Penner, E. K., Davison, M., Sanabria, T., Hanselman, P., Domina, T., & Penner, A. M. (2022). Reining in Punitive Discipline: Recent Trends in Exclusionary School Discipline Disparities. Socius, 8.
- Bell, C., & Puckett, T. (2023). I Want To Learn But They Won’t Let Me: Exploring the Impact of School Discipline on Academic Achievement. Urban Education, 58(10), 2658-2688.
- Pearman, F. A., Curran, F. C., Fisher, B., & Gardella, J. (2019). Are Achievement Gaps Related to Discipline Gaps? Evidence From National Data. AERA Open, 5(4).
- Nowicki, Jacqueline M. “K-12 Education: Discipline Disparities for Black Students, Boys, and Students with Disabilities. Report to Congressional Requesters. GAO-18-258.” US Government Accountability Office (2018).
- Kyere, E., Joseph, A., & Wei, K. (2018). Alternative to zero-tolerance policies and out-of-school suspensions: A multitiered centered perspective. Journal of Ethnic & Cultural Diversity in Social Work, 29(5), 421–436
- Secondary Discipline: The Unintended Consequences of Zero Tolerance School Discipline for Low-Income Black and Latina Mothers (2018).
- ‘Punitive discipline makes school feel like a prison, not a community’ (2019)
School Funding (LCAP & LCFF)
- The Hidden Cost of California’s Harsh School Discipline: And the Localized Economic Benefits from Suspending Fewer High School Students (2017)
- Improving School Climate through LCAPs: Analysis of the School Climate Priority in Year 2 Annual Updates of Local Control Accountability Plans for California’s 50 Largest School Districts (2016)
- Los Angeles LCAPs Reviewed: How did the 80+ school districts address the needs of foster youth in the Year 1 Local Control and Accountability Plans? (2015)
Law Enforcement
- Cops and No Counselors: How the Lack of School Mental Health Staff is Harming Students (2019)
- Restorative Justice Now! A Community Review of Alexandria City Public Schools’ Implementation of Restorative Justice (2016)
- The 5th Annual Denver Community Accountability Report Card 2014 – 2015 School Year (2016)
- Lessons In Racial Justice and Movement Building: Dismantling the School-to-Prison Pipeline in Colorado and Nationally (2014)
School to Prison Pipeline (Racial Bias and Discrimination)
- 11 Million Days Lost: Race, Discipline, and Safety at U.S. Public Schools (2018)
- The Unequal Impact of Suspension on the Opportunity to Learn in California: What the 2016-17 Rates Tell Us About Progress (2018)
- Girlhood Interrupted: The Erasure of Black Girls’ Childhood (2017)
- Lost Instruction: The Disparate Impact of the School Discipline Gap in California (2017)
Restorative Justice & Practices (Alternative Practices)
- Moving Beyond Retribution: Alternatives to Punishment in a Society Dominated by the School-to-Prison-Pipeline (2017)
- What do we know about school discipline reform? (2017)
- Evidence From Schools Implementing Restorative Practices (2014)
- Restorative Practices: Fostering Healthy Relationships & Promoting Positive Discipline in Schools (2014)
School-Wide Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports (Alternative Practices)
- What do we know about school discipline reform? (2017)
- A Literature Map of Dropout Prevention Interventions for Students with Disabilities (2014)
- Lessons In Racial Justice and Movement Building: Dismantling the School-to-Prison Pipeline in Colorado and Nationally (2014)
- Effectiveness of Schoolwide Positive Behavior Interventions and Supports in Reducing Racially Inequitable Disciplinary Exclusion (2013)